Best annuity companies (April 2025)

The top annuity companies right now are Athene, New York Life, MassMutual, Global Atlantic, and Nationwide, based on their financial strength and customer satisfaction.

These companies offer a mix of fixed, indexed, and immediate annuities to fit different needs.

When picking an annuity company, I think it's key to check their financial ratings from agencies like A.M. Best and Moody's.

This tells you how likely they are to keep their promises long-term. I also like to look at things like fees, surrender charges, and payout options.

It's worth noting that the best company for you depends on your specific goals. Some companies offer the best MYGA annuities for steady income, while others shine with fixed indexed annuities for growth potential.

I suggest getting quotes from a few top-rated companies to compare. That way, you can find the best fit for your retirement plans.

Top 20 companies by fixed annuity sales

Annuity company
AM Best rating
Full review
A+ Rating (Superior)
A Rating (Excellent)
A++ Rating (Superior)
A Rating (Excellent)
A+ Rating (Superior)
A++ Rating (Superior)
A+ Rating (Superior)
A- Rating (Excellent)
A Rating (Excellent)
A+ Rating (Superior)
A- Rating (Excellent)
A++ Rating (Superior)
A Rating (Excellent)
A+ Rating (Superior)
EquiTrust logo
B++ Rating (Good)
A+ Rating (Superior)
A+ Rating (Superior)
A++ Rating (Superior)
A+ Rating (Superior)
A- Rating (Excellent)

What are annuities?

Annuities are financial products, used mostly for retirement planning. They're contracts between consumers and insurance companies.

When I'm ready to buy an annuity, I give the insurance company some money, and they promise to pay me back over time. Payments are made to me at the end of a certain amount of time (like 3, 5, or 7 years) or may continue for my entire lifetime.

There are different types of annuities:

  • Fixed annuities: These pay a set amount each month
  • Fixed Indexed annuities: Payments are tied to a market index
  • Variable annuities: Payments can change based on investment value

Some key features of annuities:

  • Guaranteed income for life
  • Tax-deferred growth
  • Death benefits for beneficiaries

Annuities can be helpful for steady income in retirement. But they can be complex and have fees. It's important to research different annuity products before buying.

Some annuity offerings let me choose how long I want payments. Options include:

  • My lifetime
  • A set number of years
  • As long as me or my spouse is alive

I think annuities can be a good way to create predictable income. But they're just one piece of a retirement plan.

Types of annuities

There are quite a few types of annuities out there. Let me break down some of the main ones for you.

Fixed annuities are pretty straightforward. They give you a guaranteed interest rate and regular payments. It's like a savings account, but with an insurance company.

Variable annuities are a bit different. Some of your money gets invested in the stock market, so your payments can go up or down. It's riskier, but there's potential for higher returns.

Fixed indexed annuities are a mix of fixed and variable. They're tied to a market index, like the S&P 500. You get some market gains, but with less risk.

There are also immediate and deferred annuities. Immediate ones start paying you right away, while deferred ones start later.

Some other types include:

  • Income annuities (for steady income)
  • Qualified longevity annuity contract (QLAC)
  • Multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) for fixed rates

Many annuities offer riders too. These are add-ons that can give you extra benefits, like guaranteed income or death benefits.

Each type has its pros and cons. It's important to consider your goals and risk tolerance when picking one.

How much does an annuity cost?

The cost of an annuity can vary a lot. I've found that it depends on the type you choose and how much money you put in. Most companies require at least $5,000 to $10,000 to start.

The amount you put in an annuity also affects how much income you'll get later. A bigger lump sum premium usually means more money for you down the road.

Don't forget about taxes! The money you put in isn't taxed right away. But when you start getting payments, you mightowe income tax on the earnings.

It's smart to shop around. I've noticed that costs can be quite different between companies. Some might offer a better guaranteed interest rate or lower fees.

Remember, an annuity is a long-term commitment. I always suggest talking to an annuity broker before jumping in.

Are annuities a good idea?

Annuities can be a good strategy for some folks, but they're not for everyone.

Here are some pros of annuities: 

  • Guaranteed income in retirement
  • Tax-deferred growth
  • Protection from market crashes

But there are downsides too: 

  • High surrender fees (sometimes 10%)
  • Limited access to your money
  • Lower returns than other investments

Annuities might make sense if I'm worried about outliving my savings. They can provide steady income, kind of like a personal pension.

My risk tolerance and time horizon matter a lot here. If I'm close to retirement and can't handle much market risk, an annuity could be a safe option.

But if I've got time on my side, I might do better investing in a 401(k) or IRA. These accounts offer more flexibility and potentially higher returns. However, I could lose all of my savings in a stock market crash.

It's smart to chat with an annuity broker before buying an annuity. They can help figure out if it fits with your retirement goals and overall financial plan.

How to choose the best annuity company

Picking the right annuity company can be tricky. I'll share some tips to help you find a good fit.

First, I'd look at financial strength ratings. These show how stable a company is. A high rating means they're more likely to pay out in the future.

Customer satisfaction is key too. I'd check online reviews and ask friends for their experiences.

Here are some other factors to consider:

  • Annuity options: More choices = better chance of finding what you need
  • Investment options: For indexed annuities, a wide range is good
  • Customer service: You want responsive, helpful support
  • Comdex score: This combines different ratings into one number

I'd also talk to a licensed insurance agent. They can help match your needs to the right company and product.

Don't forget to compare quotes from several companies. Rates and terms can vary a lot.

Lastly, think about your financial goals. Some companies specialize in certain types of annuities. Pick one that aligns with your plans.

Annuity FAQ

Here are answers to common questions I get about rates, ratings, and financial stability:

Which companies offer the best rates for annuities?

MassMutual, Athene, and Global Atlantic tend to have competitive annuity rates. I've seen EquiTrust offer some of the highest fixed annuity rates lately. Athene is known for decent indexed annuity rates.

Rates change often, so it's smart to compare current offers from multiple companies. I usually recommend getting quotes from at least 3-5 providers before buying.

What do insurance company ratings mean?

Ratings from agencies like A.M. Best and Moody's show a company's financial strength. An A++ or AAA rating is the best. It means the company is very likely to pay claims.

Lower ratings like B or C suggest more risk. I avoid companies rated below B++ for annuities. Strong ratings are crucial since annuities are long-term contracts.

What happens if an annuity company goes out of business?

State guaranty associations protect annuity owners if a company fails. Coverage limits vary by state, usually between $100,000 to $500,000 per person.

Any amount over the limit could be lost. That's why I spread large annuities across multiple highly-rated companies.

Are there any annuity companies currently experiencing financial difficulties?

As of April 2025, I'm not aware of any major annuity providers in serious financial trouble. The industry has been stable lately.

Still, it's wise to check ratings before buying. Even strong companies can have issues. I keep an eye on financial news for any concerns.

Have any annuity companies gone out of business recently?

No big annuity companies have failed in the last few years. The last major failure I recall was Executive Life in 1991.

Stricter regulations since then have helped. But past performance doesn't guarantee future stability. I always emphasize choosing financially strong providers.